REVIEW | Silver Pines

REVIEW | Silver Pines

We live in an age where psychological horror is going through a renaissance. While there is no guidebook on how to make a decent psychological horror game, Silent Hill has been the de facto gold standard in both story telling, combat, and interesting enemy design that fits the world around it. With the recent revival of the Silent Hill series, we have had a number of new entries that deviate somewhat from that formula, and still find a way to appease the fandom. Silver Pines in one such game that I feel has done everything by the so called “guidebook”, and and yet still feels more like a Silent Hill game than most others.

Silver Pines is creative in its approach to game design with a unique blend of 2D/3D graphics that helps give it stand out from other games on the market. It has an incredibly moody setting with tons of action, survival horror elements, and a top notch voice acting cast that really helps sell the immersion. I can’t tell you how much fun I had playing through the game, so you’ll have to read more down below to get my final thoughts.

ℹ️ Reviewed on PC | Review code provided by PR/publisher, this review is the personal opinion of the writer.

DeveloperWych Elm
PublisherTeam17

Things I liked!

  • Blending of 2D & 3D Graphics | By far the most striking part of Silver Pines has to be its graphics. It is quite rare these days that you see a development team put in the level of detail that Silver Pines has. The world is quite clearly 3D, but you navigate on a 2D plane, and while your character is 2D also, he comes with all the abilities and moves you would expect a fully 3D action game to have.

    The weather elements also help sell the immersion with rain, wind, thunder, and debris all flying around and affecting the world around it. Despite being such a stark contrast, the enemies, characters, and certain key environments work well together to create a cohesive looking game that weirdly feels natural.
  • An Open World Metroidvania | At first Silver Pines might seem like your typical psychological horror game. But at its core, it is a metroidvania type game. You explore the town of Riverside as you please with certain areas cut off due to a certain item not being obtained. In similar Metroidvania fashion, some of these are totally optional areas, but traversing back to previously locked areas wields special items or rewards.

    To help you navigate, a detailed map mechanic is available that lets you track, mark, and even take photographs with your camera. These can be added to the map so you know where to come back to later if you so wish. The camera mechanic is especially one I was fond of as sometimes looking back over notes wasn’t all that easy to remember, but a photo really helped.

  • Puzzles Tied To Progression | Puzzles are everywhere in Silver Pines, and even though some are optional, most are tied to progression. I have to take a moment to thank the developers here, because I feel puzzles these days have gotten a little out of hand, and while the puzzles aren’t necessarily easy to complete, the environmental storytelling gives you enough clues on how to figure it out, usually with ease.

    I wouldn’t say any puzzle gave me too much of a headache. Again, the average player I think will get through it relatively easy, as long as they are keeping an eye out, and reading whatever they find. Once puzzles are complete, they will usually open the next area or reward you with what you need to progress.

  • The Boss Fights | Silver Pines is full of boss fights. Some are forced, and some are optional. They are usually found in red rooms, and the light usually protrudes from wherever they can be found. It sort of reminded me of bosses found in games like Elden Ring, where there was a wall of light letting you know that a boss was coming.

    Bosses are fairly aggressive and hit you with a wave of attacks that don’t confirm to other enemy types. Mastering them can be frustrating at times, but equally fill you with excitement. At one point, I was actively hunting down as many bosses as I could because I found them so fun to fight.

  • Combat | The combat in Silver Pines is very good. It is simple in its approach but works extremely well. Melee attacks make up the base of all combat with left mouse swinging your equipped melee weapon. It starts you off with a knife, but later you can find other weapons such as baseball bats, crowbars, and even sledgehammers. Next, there are firearms. Pistols, Shotgun variants, rifles, machine guns, and even nail guns can be used to dispatch enemies in spectacular fashion.

    Guns do feel a little overpowered at times, but they can hit almost anything in the environment and create devastating destruction at times creating a ton of particle effects that really sell the power of the weapon. For example, firing a shotgun through a locked door will shatter it sending splinters everywhere, before finally hitting the enemy the other side. It’s really quite something. Aiming your gun is done by moving the mouse up and down so you can freely choose where to aim at an enemy. While I don’t think it matters where you hit them, there are some enemies that crawl, and some that fly.

    Finally, for all you grenade lovers out there, Red can use Molotov Cocktails to set enemies on fire if you are lucky enough to get a good aim.

  • The Story | I don’t want to spoil the story too much here as it is really good, but essentially you play a private detective called Red Walker who is looking for a person called Eddie Velvet. He’s a musician who is accused of murdering a local woman from the town of Riverside. While the game does keep a lot from you in terms of who your employer is, what becomes more interesting as time goes on is the clear psychological toll this investigation has on your character. While he may not be directly involved with the case he’s hired to solve, Red has his own demons to contend with and something about Riverside is bringing it out of him.

    There are some genuinely creepy moments when Red has an “episode”, and the way it is presented is very clever and well polished. As time went on, I found myself wanting to know more about Red and his own problems rather than finding Eddie. Overall it is well written, and goes head to head with some of the better psychological horror stories I have played through.

  • Memory Fragments | Red can equip certain charms found throughout the town of Riverside that give him a competitive edge. There are sixteen to find in total. At the start of the game you can equip one, but there are these bird cages that contain fragment parts in them that you can find when exploring. Combine four of these together and you get to equip another one, stacking abilities and making you stronger.

    By far my favorite fragment to equipment was the swimming stamina. This allowed me to reach previously cut off areas, as previously I would just drown and respawn.

  • Music & SFX | Music is very important in horror games. It helps build tension and immerse you in its world of terror. Silver Pines does a great job at selling you the horror that is found in each area. Sewers are objectively one of the best areas for this. It’s dark, damp, and visibility is bad even with a torch equipped. Music drones at you with a loud pulsing beat that makes you wonder where enemies are coming from. It also has 3D audio so when enemies moan at you and bosses rush you, you can usually hear the direction as well.

    Voice acting is another example of what Silver Pines does well. Red is portrayed perfectly by a confused, inquisitive sounding detective, who at most times sounds like he walking through a dream. All cast members have great voice acting too, with special mentions going to the Sheriff, and the Digging Man. To be honest, I loved the digging man because no matter what you say or do to him, he just doesn’t give a shit.

Mixed & disliked!

  • Enemy Design | With the exception of bosses, the enemy design can be a little lacking. Almost all enemies in Silver Pines are portrayed by shadowy looking figures. It is a shame given how detailed the rest of the characters are, and for me, when I am interacting with enemies so frequently, I would have liked a little more variation. Enemies felt extremely basic to the point of minor annoyance. I found myself at times ignoring them by dodging past them just to get certain areas over with.
  • Lack of Unique Characters | Almost all psychological horror games have supporting characters that are there to support the protagonist in some way. Whether it is to guide them unconventionally by asking the player to question their motives, or to try and divert us from from our end goal. Looking back at recent games like Silent Hill Townfall for example, both Richard and Zoe had motives to keep the protagonist from advancing, or manipulating us to serve their own agenda.

    Supporting characters in Silver Pines offer almost no incentive to talk to. Some can give you items, but they offer no other support past that point. As I became more and more involved in Red’s backstory, I started to want more from the small encounters I did have with these characters.
How long did I play the review before publishing? 12 hours
How long to beat the story? 12 hours
How long to Complete the game 100%? 20 hours +
How many Achievements did I earn before publishing? 15
You'll love this game if you like these: Silent Hill, Well Dweller, Dreadmoor

Score: 85/100

Silver Pines is an entertaining game that plays it safe by following tried and tested methods from the psychological horror playbook. However its unique art style in a metroidvania presentation make it an interesting combination to explore all it has to offer. horror fan or not, Silver Pines has something to offer you.